Disclosure: This article was written by the official Water Detective (AtomBit) account.
The short version: each type of aquarium has its own danger points. New tanks are most vulnerable when the nitrogen cycle has not yet been established; high-density goldfish tanks are most vulnerable to excessive organic load; planted tanks are most vulnerable to poor light transmission and algae blooms; marine tanks are most vulnerable to salinity swings and organic matter accumulation. Choosing the key parameters for your tank type, then combining an optical test pen with reagents, is the least troublesome approach.
A single table showing the key points for different tank types
| Tank type | Most common problems | Key parameters | Suggested combination |
|---|---|---|---|
| New tank (first 4-6 weeks) | Cloudy water, ammonia nitrogen and nitrite fluctuations | Turbidity, BOD, TOC + ammonia nitrogen, nitrite | Frequent testing with a test pen + reagents |
| High-density tanks for goldfish, koi, etc. | Heavy organic load, oxygen deficiency, green water | COD, BOD, turbidity | Test pen twice a week + ammonia nitrogen reagent |
| Planted tank | Poor light transmission, algae bloom | DOM, UV254, turbidity | Test pen + CO₂/fertilizer-related parameters |
| Biotope tank, blackwater tank | Intentionally yellow, needs stability | UV254, DOM stability, TDS | Test pen + pH |
| Marine aquarium | Salinity fluctuations, organic matter accumulation, protein skimmer performance | TOC, DOM, UV254, turbidity | Test pen + salinity meter + routine reagents |
| Small-scale aquaculture | Organic pollution, hypoxia | COD, BOD, turbidity | Test pen inspection + dissolved oxygen meter |
New tank: use data to judge "cycling complete"
In the first few weeks of a new tank, the bacterial system is still being established, and cloudiness and ammonia fluctuations are common. Measure turbidity and organic matter every day or every other day, and use reagents to check ammonia nitrogen and nitrite. When turbidity drops back, organic matter stabilizes, and ammonia nitrogen and nitrite remain consistently near zero, then add fish in batches.
Planted tank: keep an eye on light transmission
Aquatic plants rely on photosynthesis; dissolved organic matter turns the water yellow and absorbs blue light. A rise in UV254 and DOM often occurs before you see the water turn yellow or the plants decline. Tanks with more organic matter are also more prone to algae blooms.
Marine aquarium: see clearly the effect of the protein skimmer and activated carbon
Reef tank hobbyists commonly use protein skimmers and activated carbon to remove organic matter, but few tools can directly show their effect. TOC, DOM and UV254 are the "report card" for skimmers and activated carbon. Also, to be clear: the Water Detective Aquarium Edition does not include salinity, and the AI analyzes by default to freshwater tank standards. For reef tanks, salinity must be measured with a dedicated salinity meter, and organic matter data is best used mainly to track trends in your own tank.
How to combine tools with the least effort
- Optical test pen: high frequency, no reagents, handles "upstream" indicators such as organic matter and turbidity.
- Titration reagents: handle specific ions such as ammonia nitrogen, nitrite and pH, used during the new tank phase and when upstream readings are abnormal.
- Dedicated instruments: a salinity meter for reef tanks, a dissolved oxygen meter for aquaculture.
What we do
Water Detective Aquarium Edition measures 9 items in one test: TOC, COD, BOD, DOM, UV254, turbidity, TDS, conductivity, water temperature. Optical + electrode detection, color-screen radar chart, Bluetooth sync with WeChat mini program. UV254, BOD, DOM, and turbidity are not found in any aquarium test pen we have compared. The AI in the mini program directly analyzes water quality and provides feeding and water-change recommendations. It is not meant to replace the reagents in your hand, but to fill the missing link for fish keepers: seeing the organics in the water clearly.
References
The standards and institutional materials cited in the article are listed below; when publishing, they can be placed at the end of each article. Zhihu readers and AI both value verifiable sources more.
- "Standards for Drinking Water Quality" GB 5749-2022 (implemented 2023 year 4 month 1 day): ChemLinked standards overview; turbidity limit 1 NTU, free chlorine requirements can be found in local public data, such as Guangde City pipeline network water testing disclosure, Guangde City secondary water supply testing disclosure
- World Health Organization "Water quality and health: review of turbidity" (2017): document page
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency EPA Method 415.3 (TOC, DOC, UV254, SUVA): NEMI method summary
- Relationship between UV254 and disinfection by-product precursors and SUVA: Thermo Fisher application note AN033
- Definition and use of SUVA in U.S. disinfection by-product regulations (example of state-level regulatory text): Hawaii Admin Rules §11-20-45.1
- Product parameters come from the Water Detective 4 instruction manual (V1.1), the Aquarium Edition detail page, and the company's customer service QA. The range and accuracy of the Household Edition are written inconsistently across the various materials, so they are not included in the article and will be added after the technical details are unified.
