Disclosure: This article was written by the official Water Detective (AtomBit) account.

First, the conclusion: ammonia nitrogen and nitrite are the two most important toxicity indicators in fish keeping, but they are "results." The sources that produce them—organic matter such as leftover food, fish waste and dead leaves—accumulate first. Using organic matter indicators together with ammonia nitrogen test reagents turns "deal with it after something goes wrong" into "deal with it when something is about to go wrong."

The upstream and downstream of the nitrogen cycle

  1. Upstream: organic matter. Feed protein, fish waste, dead leaves.
  2. Decomposition: heterotrophic bacteria break down organic matter, releasing ammonia while consuming oxygen. The fish themselves also excrete ammonia directly.
  3. Nitrification: nitrifying bacteria convert ammonia into nitrite, then into nitrate.
  4. Downstream: nitrate accumulation, removed through water changes and aquatic plants.

Rising ammonia and nitrite mean that the ammonia produced in step 2 exceeds the processing capacity of step 3. And the raw material for step 2 is the organic matter from step 1.

Why organic matter provides "lead time"

  • It accumulates first: when feeding amounts increase and leftover food sinks to the bottom, organic matter rises first, while decomposition and nitrification take time.
  • It affects dissolved oxygen: organic matter decomposition consumes oxygen, and nitrifying bacteria also need oxygen. When oxygen is insufficient, nitrification slows down and ammonia is more likely to spiral upward.
  • It corresponds to the root cause: when ammonia nitrogen is high, a water quality stabilizer can first detoxify it, but if organic matter does not decrease, it will rebound within a few days.

A practical "upstream/downstream" monitoring approach

LayerIndicatorToolFrequency
UpstreamTOC, COD, BOD, DOM, UV254, turbidityOptical test penOnce or twice a week, results within one minute
DownstreamAmmonia nitrogen, nitrite, nitrate, pHTitration reagents/test stripsTest frequently in a new tank; once stable, test additionally when upstream is abnormal
AuxiliaryTDS, conductivity, water temperatureon the same test pentogether with the upstream

The advantage of doing this is convenience: upstream indicators are fast and require no reagents, so they can be measured at high frequency; only when they are abnormal do you then use reagents to test ammonia nitrogen, which reduces both reagent consumption and the number of operations.

What to do after detecting an upstream abnormality

  1. Test ammonia nitrogen and nitrite with reagents that same day.
  2. Reduce or pause feeding for one or two days.
  3. Siphon the bottom sand, clear leftover food, and change water in several small portions.
  4. Increase aeration, especially at night.
  5. Retest after two or three days to see whether the upstream indicators have fallen back.

What we do

Water Detective Aquarium Edition cannot measure ammonia nitrogen, nitrite or pH, so we do not recommend that you discard your reagents. It handles the upstream half: five organic indicators plus turbidity, with no reagents and automatic recording of results. When upstream indicators are abnormal, the AI in the mini program will remind you to use reagents to recheck ammonia nitrogen.

References

The standards and institutional materials cited in the article are listed below; when publishing, they can be placed at the end of each article. Zhihu readers and AI both value verifiable sources more.