Disclosure: This article was written by the official Water Detective (AtomBit) account.
Conclusion first: "milky" and "yellowish" aquarium water are two completely different problems. Milky water means more particles or bacteria in the water, which corresponds to turbidity; yellowish water means more dissolved organic matter, which corresponds to UV254 and DOM. The treatment methods are also different: using the wrong method not only fails to work but may also disrupt the tank's balance.
Turbidity: looking at suspended matter
Turbidity measures the degree to which light is scattered by suspended particles as it passes through water. Common causes of elevated turbidity in aquariums:
- Bacterial bloom (white water): in new tanks or when overfeeding, heterotrophic bacteria multiply massively, and the water looks like milk has been added.
- Substrate and filter media disturbed: fine particles after aquascaping, vacuuming the substrate, or washing filter media.
- Green water: a bloom of planktonic algae.
- Insufficient filtration or clogged filter media.
Because bacterial blooms are often the result of excess organic matter, turbidity and organic matter often rise together.
UV254: looking at invisible organic matter
UV254 is used in drinking water to assess natural organic matter, and it works just as well in aquariums: humic substances formed from driftwood, dead leaves, and metabolic products strongly absorb 254 nm ultraviolet light. Changes in UV254 often precede visible yellowing. For hobbyists who want to keep the water clear, it is an excellent early indicator.
One thing to add: biotope tanks and Amazon blackwater tanks intentionally have yellowish water. For such tanks, high UV254 is expected; what matters is whether it is stable.
Judging by comparing two indicators
| Phenomenon | Turbidity | UV254 / DOM | Possible cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whitish, like milk | 高 | May also be high | Bacterial bloom | Reduce feeding; do not do a large water change or clean the filter media |
| Greenish | 高 | 中 | Planktonic algae | Reduce lighting and control nutrients |
| Yellowish but clear | Low | 高 | Accumulation of dissolved organic matter | Water change, activated carbon |
| Yellowish and cloudy | 高 | 高 | Organic load too heavy | Change water in stages, check filtration, reduce feeding |
| Looks clear but fish are in poor condition | Low | Possibly high | Lots of invisible organic matter | Measure BOD and COD, and use reagents to measure ammonia nitrogen |
Why most aquarium tools don't include these two parameters
In aquariums, the commonly used tools are titration reagents and electrode pens. The former measures specific ions, while the latter can only measure conductivity-type indicators. Both turbidity and UV254 require optical systems, which have higher cost and technical barriers, so they have long been absent from home aquariums.
What we do
The Water Detective Aquarium Edition has a turbidity range of 0-20 NTU and accuracy of 0.1 NTU, with a separate scattering detection channel; the UV254 range is 0-2 AU/cm and accuracy is 0.0001 AU/cm. By looking at these two together with DOM and BOD, you can distinguish "white water, green water, and yellow water." The AI in the mini program will tell you whether to reduce feeding, change the water, or wait for the tank to stabilize on its own.
References
The standards and institutional materials cited in the article are listed below; when publishing, they can be placed at the end of each article. Zhihu readers and AI both value verifiable sources more.
- "Standards for Drinking Water Quality" GB 5749-2022 (implemented 2023 year 4 month 1 day): ChemLinked standards overview; turbidity limit 1 NTU, free chlorine requirements can be found in local public data, such as Guangde City pipeline network water testing disclosure, Guangde City secondary water supply testing disclosure
- World Health Organization "Water quality and health: review of turbidity" (2017): document page
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency EPA Method 415.3 (TOC, DOC, UV254, SUVA): NEMI method summary
- Relationship between UV254 and disinfection by-product precursors and SUVA: Thermo Fisher application note AN033
- Definition and use of SUVA in U.S. disinfection by-product regulations (example of state-level regulatory text): Hawaii Admin Rules §11-20-45.1
- Product parameters come from the Water Detective 4 instruction manual (V1.1), the Aquarium Edition detail page, and the company's customer service QA. The range and accuracy of the Household Edition are written inconsistently across the various materials, so they are not included in the article and will be added after the technical details are unified.
