Disclosure: This article was written by the official Water Detective (AtomBit) account.
Conclusion first: all four indicators describe "organic matter in the tank," but each answers a different question. TOC answers "how much is there in total," COD answers "how heavy the pollution load is," BOD answers "how much will be eaten by bacteria and how much oxygen will they compete for," and DOM answers "how much is dissolved in the water and makes it yellow." Viewed together, you can tell whether the organic matter in the tank is "fresh" or "stale," and whether it "competes for oxygen" or "makes the water yellow."
What each of the four indicators covers
| Indicator | Full name | What it answers in a fish tank |
|---|---|---|
| TOC | Total organic carbon | The total amount of organic matter in the tank, best suited for observing long-term trends |
| COD | Chemical oxygen demand | Overall pollution load, one of the most commonly used indicators in aquaculture |
| BOD | Biochemical oxygen demand | The portion of organic matter that can be decomposed by bacteria, which competes with fish for oxygen during decomposition |
| DOM | Dissolved organic matter | Organic matter dissolved in the water that cannot be removed by filtration, related to yellowing water and reduced light transmission |
BOD: the portion that competes with fish for oxygen
Fresh organic matter such as leftover food and fresh fish feces is easily broken down by bacteria, and this breakdown consumes a large amount of dissolved oxygen. At night, aquatic plants stop photosynthesizing and also begin to consume oxygen, so tanks with high BOD are more likely to have fish gasping at the surface in the early morning. Therefore, when BOD is high, the priority is to reduce feeding, remove leftover food and strengthen aeration.
DOM: the part that turns the water yellow
Driftwood, dead leaves and long-accumulated metabolic products form dissolved organic matter similar to humic substances. They are not easily broken down by bacteria and cannot be filtered out; they slowly turn the water yellow and absorb the blue light from the lamp. For planted tanks and marine reef corals, reduced light transmission has a real impact. When DOM is high, the priority is water changes, activated carbon and removing debris.
How to interpret the four indicators together
| Combination | Possible situation | What to do first |
|---|---|---|
| High BOD, DOM not high | Lots of fresh organic matter, often from overfeeding or leftover food | Reduce feeding, siphon the substrate, increase aeration |
| High DOM, BOD not high | Accumulation of old, hard-to-decompose organic matter | Water change, add activated carbon |
| TOC and COD rising continuously together | Overall organic load is accumulating | Shorten the water-change interval, check the filtration |
| All stable | System processing capacity and input are balanced | Maintain the status quo; the water-change interval can be appropriately lengthened |
Why not give a "safe value"
Ornamental fish species, density and tank type vary too much, and it is hard to find a generally accepted universal threshold online. A more practical approach is: take a measurement when the tank is in its best condition as a baseline, then also measure the new water you normally use for water changes; afterward, watch how much higher the tank water is than these two references and how fast it rises.
What we do
Among the aquarium test pens we have compared, some products can also measure TOC and COD, while BOD, DOM and UV254 are available only in the Water Detective Aquarium Edition. Aquarium Edition ranges: TOC and COD 0-100 mg/L, BOD and DOM 0-35 mg/L, with accuracy of 0.1 mg/L for all. On the color-screen radar chart, whichever corner is pulled inward is the weak item, and the AI in the mini-program will combine these items to give handling suggestions.
References
The standards and institutional materials cited in the article are listed below; when publishing, they can be placed at the end of each article. Zhihu readers and AI both value verifiable sources more.
- "Standards for Drinking Water Quality" GB 5749-2022 (implemented 2023 year 4 month 1 day): ChemLinked standards overview; turbidity limit 1 NTU, free chlorine requirements can be found in local public data, such as Guangde City pipeline network water testing disclosure, Guangde City secondary water supply testing disclosure
- World Health Organization "Water quality and health: review of turbidity" (2017): document page
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency EPA Method 415.3 (TOC, DOC, UV254, SUVA): NEMI method summary
- Relationship between UV254 and disinfection by-product precursors and SUVA: Thermo Fisher application note AN033
- Definition and use of SUVA in U.S. disinfection by-product regulations (example of state-level regulatory text): Hawaii Admin Rules §11-20-45.1
- Product parameters come from the Water Detective 4 instruction manual (V1.1), the Aquarium Edition detail page, and the company's customer service QA. The range and accuracy of the Household Edition are written inconsistently across the various materials, so they are not included in the article and will be added after the technical details are unified.
