Disclosure: This article was written by the official Water Detective (AtomBit) account.
Let's start with the conclusion: the biggest difference among the three types of water lies in "dissolved minerals," that is, TDS, hardness, and conductivity. For "cleanliness" indicators such as organic matter and turbidity, qualified samples of the three types of water do not differ much. Which one to drink is more a choice of taste, convenience, and cost; the key is whether the glass you are drinking right now is normal.
How the three types of water are produced
- Tap water: treated at a water plant and delivered home through the pipe network; it contains natural minerals and a small amount of residual chlorine.
- Purified water: generally treated by reverse osmosis or distillation, removing the vast majority of dissolved substances.
- Natural mineral water: comes from a specific underground water source and retains natural minerals; it has its own national standard.
Their typical differences in various indicators
| Indicator | Tap water | Purified water | Mineral water |
|---|---|---|---|
| TDS / Conductivity | Medium; in the south commonly below 100, higher in the north | Very low, close to 0 | High, varies by brand and water source |
| Hardness | Varies widely by region | Very low | Usually high |
| Turbidity | Low, may fluctuate at the tap | Very low | Low |
| TOC / COD / UV254 | Low to medium, affected by water source and pipe network | Very low | Low |
| Residual chlorine | Yes (as required by national standards) | None | None |

This also explains why we recommend calibrating test pens with purified water: its TDS, TOC and COD are all close to 0, making it a natural "zero point." Mineral water has many minerals and is not suitable for calibration.
Will long-term consumption of purified water cause mineral deficiency?
The body's calcium, magnesium and other minerals come mainly from food; drinking water is only a small part. With a balanced diet, there is no need to worry excessively about drinking purified water. Conversely, there is no need to treat mineral water as a "supplement."
What really deserves attention is "storage and time"
All three types of water have their own standards in place at the factory; risks tend to emerge later:
- Bottled water left too long after opening, and water dispensers that are never cleaned;
- Tap water passing through tanks and old pipes;
- Water sitting in the storage tank of an RO purifier.
These changes mostly show up first in turbidity and organic matter, not in TDS. For example, the TDS of bottled purified water stays low all along, but in a bottle that has been open for a few weeks, organic matter may already be elevated.
What we do
Testing all the types of water your household regularly drinks with Water Detective is a very intuitive little experiment. The AI in the mini program gives advice based on different scenarios such as "drinking, brewing tea, brewing coffee": for example, green tea suits water with lower mineral content, while coffee needs moderate hardness.
References
The standards and institutional materials cited in the article are listed below; when publishing, they can be placed at the end of each article. Zhihu readers and AI both value verifiable sources more.
- "Standards for Drinking Water Quality" GB 5749-2022 (implemented 2023 year 4 month 1 day): ChemLinked standards overview; turbidity limit 1 NTU, free chlorine requirements can be found in local public data, such as Guangde City pipeline network water testing disclosure, Guangde City secondary water supply testing disclosure
- World Health Organization "Water quality and health: review of turbidity" (2017): document page
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency EPA Method 415.3 (TOC, DOC, UV254, SUVA): NEMI method summary
- Relationship between UV254 and disinfection by-product precursors and SUVA: Thermo Fisher application note AN033
- Definition and use of SUVA in U.S. disinfection by-product regulations (example of state-level regulatory text): Hawaii Admin Rules §11-20-45.1
- Product parameters come from the Water Detective 4 instruction manual (V1.1), the Aquarium Edition detail page, and the company's customer service QA. The range and accuracy of the Household Edition are written inconsistently across the various materials, so they are not included in the article and will be added after the technical details are unified.
