Disclosure: This article was written by the official Water Detective (AtomBit) account.

Bottom line first: the "6 months, 12 months" in a water purifier manual are calculated based on average water quality and average water usage. If your water quality is a bit worse or your household is a bit larger, the filter cartridge will become saturated sooner; if you use less water and have good water quality, you may be replacing it too early. A more accurate approach is to measure both the inlet and outlet water at the same time and see whether the "removal performance" is declining.

What each type of filter cartridge handles

Filter cartridgeWhat it removesIndicator that changes first upon failure
PP cottonLarge particles such as sediment and rust debrisTurbidity
Activated carbon (pre/post)Organic matter, residual chlorine, odorsUV254、TOC、COD
超滤膜Fine particles, colloids, most bacteriaTurbidity, UV254
RO反渗透膜Most dissolved substances (salts, small-molecule organic matter, etc.)TDS, conductivity, and then TOC

See the problem? Only RO membrane failure shows up mainly in TDS. When PP cotton, activated carbon or ultrafiltration membranes fail, TDS barely changes. Using a TDS pen to decide whether an ultrafiltration water purifier needs a cartridge change is like using a bathroom scale to take your temperature.

Water Detective 4 product image
Water Detective 4 — Product reference; refer to the product documentation for the specific version and configuration.

Why activated carbon is most easily overlooked

Activated carbon adsorbs organic matter through its internal micropores, and once full it is saturated. After saturation it gives no "alarm" whatsoever: the water is still clear, the flow rate is unchanged, and TDS is unchanged. What is worse, saturated activated carbon holds a large amount of accumulated organic matter and can become a place for bacteria to grow. At that point, the UV254 and TOC of the outlet water gradually approach those of the inlet water, or even run higher.

A simple self-check method

  1. After installing a new cartridge and rinsing it as instructed, measure the inlet and outlet water once and record the "new-cartridge difference."
  2. After that, measure once a month at the same time of day.
  3. Compare the differences in turbidity, UV254, TOC, COD and TDS.
  4. When the difference shrinks to less than half of what it was with a new cartridge, it is time to consider replacing the corresponding cartridge.

A few common pitfalls

  • A new cartridge measures worse instead: new cartridges may contain substances such as glycerin used for protection, so rinse thoroughly before measuring.
  • Judging RO water by TDS alone: low TDS only shows the RO membrane is still working; the condition of the storage tank and post-activated carbon must be judged by organic matter.
  • Water purifiers left unused for a long time: after a week-long business trip, run the tap for a while to flush out the stored water before testing and drinking.

What we do

Water Detective measures all these indicators in one go. The mini program saves every record of inlet and outlet water, and the AI can directly compare two cups of water to tell you which filter stage's removal performance is declining. For a water purifier whose filter cartridges often cost hundreds of yuan each, "replace when you should, skip when you shouldn't" is itself a real saving.

References

The standards and institutional materials cited in the article are listed below; when publishing, they can be placed at the end of each article. Zhihu readers and AI both value verifiable sources more.